| This is a very personal view of what it is like to live in the Isle
of Man - as I have done for 20+ years now. I have given marks out of 10 for
various aspects of life here. My view is hopefully neutral and unbiased,
particularly if you are considering moving to the Isle of Man for tax
reasons. |
Tax (7/10)
Officially a low-tax center. Corporate tax is zero (banks
10%), personal tax maximum 18% plus capped at a certain payment level. There
are no capital-gains type taxes. This needs to be seen in perspective. Not that
many years ago, taxes were in the 5-10% bracket.
'Off-shore' is not always what it seems to be. For
example, some financial institutions are branches of UK parent companies,
rather than incorporated in the Isle of Man or other off-shore jurisdiction.
For these, computerised records are not held on the Island so privacy from
UK/EU authorities is debatable. The Island also has a VAT agreement with the UK
government. With the line between Income Tax and Customs&Excise
increasingly blurred, there must also be concerns about privacy
there.
For the seriously wealthy, there is the full range of
appropriate vehicles - trusts, private companies etc. Local tax and government
officials are very approachable. The financial services sector is strong and
there are many service providers at all cost levels. On balance though,
personal tax is not that simple an issue and still quite a bit more complicated
than corporate tax. For those facing prohibitive tax rates (30% plus), the Isle
of Man is still 'low-tax', but other jurisdictions will always be competitive.
Shop around. |
Sport (7/10)
For a small Island, sport is well-catered for. The
National Sports Centre is outstanding for a place this size. 4 all-weather
pitches are well-utilised for a wide range of sports. There are lots of active
clubs in all sports. Golf is reasonable - 5 courses of differing types,
although not cheap for casual rounds. |
Crime (7/10)
Ranks as a 'very low-crime' place if you are looking at
that as part of quality of life. There are no truly no-go areas. Until 10 years
ago hard drugs were virtually unknown. However that is changing - mostly driven
by drug-dealers from the North-West of the UK. In my view the government really
underestimates the long-term damage being caused here.
Littering is an unfortunate problem - kids in particular
just don't seem to get it. Other casual vandalism is relatively minor. Given
that it is an Island, some other crime is not a big deal. Professional car
theft, for example, is rare seeing there is only one way (the ferries) to get a
stolen car off the Island.
All in all, people care. A drug dealer trying to open up
a new area is likely to get accosted by offended locals. As a last recourse the
authorities can eject people from the Island and local magistrates are quick to
issue orders banning people from returning for several years. If crime
increases, this will be due to lack of focus by the government or simply
because they can not crack down as hard as local people might like (the Island
is signatory to all of the major human rights conventions via the UK
government). |
Education (7/10)
Local schools are not bad. Particularly bad teachers
simply don't have many schools to move on to. There is reasonable technical
education (trade-focused) beyond that, but advanced education is non-existent
i.e. people must go off the Island for university. Professional qualifications
are off-Island e.g. finance studies are not locally administered.
|
Government (6/10)
There are three levels of political representation.
National (the Manx government), town councils and parish councils. Town/parish
councils have power over relatively small items. Budget spending is
concentrated in national government. With economic prosperity over last 10
years, some long-overdue public works have been undertaken e.g. for waste
disposal. The government has to provide the full gamut of services of any
country. In that respect for a small Island it is quite efficient. However the
government sector is now quite fat relative to income-producing (in particular
finance) sectors and there must be doubt about value-for-money and ability to
right-size in bad economic times. Given very low levels of unemployment during
recent boom times, the skill base in government is lower than it might be e.g.
there have been many years of taking people without advanced education into
government service because more educated people were not
available. |
Lifestyle - indoors (5/10)
This covers 'going out' for entertainment etc. There are
quite a few reasonable restaurants, but not many good ones. Local produce is
good enough, but there is no Manx cuisine to speak of. Hotels are reasonable
but are often refurbished from older buildings. There is a down-market legacy
from the 'cheap and cheerful' heydays of mass tourism from the 1920s (before
everyone started going on cheap flights to the Mediterranean). In that respect
the Island is much like other faded resorts in the North of England. All try to
go up market, but that is an ongoing chicken-and-egg situation. Local
nightclubs are fairly tatty and youth-targeted. One distinctive local theatre
is well-supported. Cinemas are average. Realistically if you want sophisticated
entertainment/culture, you should plan on going off-Island every now and
then. |
Shopping (5/10)
A number of major UK retail chains have branches in the
Isle of Man. Choice is reasonable, but not spectacular. Again, you should plan
on going off-Island for high value and wide choice. Some items like food can be
marginally more expensive than in the UK because it all has to be imported on
the ferries. |
Housing (5/10)
There is a lot of old Victorian terraced housing in town
centers. Not too bad when refurbished, although parking and generations of damp
can be a problem. There are fairly severe restrictions on new build in the
countryside and on large conversions e.g. farmhouse to residential. A fairly
small number of developers concentrate on larger developments. New housing
estates have been built in last 15-20 years around towns. The authorities have
a mixed track record here. Some developments are downright ugly - in particular
when it comes to housing stock that will still look good in 50 years time.
Affordable housing for low-income people is probably better than most of the
UK.
Consistent economic growth over the last 15 years means
that house prices are slightly above the UK national average. The very top end
of the market (£1M+) is international-comparative and prices are
reasonable. Below that in my view there is a lot of poor value-for-money and
house prices need to come down at least 25% to be realistic. The Isle of Man is
not that special and some house prices are way out of line long-term. The
planners are trying to ensure that old housing stock is reused, but
modernisation is only viable to a limited degree. |
Weather (4/10)
Balmy climate this is not. Temperatures above 30°C
are rare. It very seldom gets really cold. Perhaps a week or two a year when
temperatures are below freezing and the Island may get some snow. Long summer
days can sometimes be absolutely gorgeous. But the winter months (November
through February) can be pretty miserable: short days, driving rain, and lots
of gales. |
Transport - off Island (3/10)
Flights: The Island is too small to attract true budget
airlines like EasyJet (flying to the Island from Liverpool only) and Ryanair.
The government has alternated between policies of a 'national airline' and
'open skies'. However done, one airline has always ended up controlling 80%+ of
airline traffic. The connections to hub airports in UK are not bad in terms of
frequency, but expect to pay dearly particularly for last-minute
flights.
Ferries: A monopoly and not particularly cheap on
average. Sailings last 3-4 hours. Like flights, ferries have been subject to
'off Island' considerations i.e. if the operator may have other
interests.
The Isle of Man is a captive audience if you run an
effective monopoly. The government has neither the power nor the will to
negotiate hard on off-Island transport costs. No-one is to blame really. Just a
fact of life here. |
The future (6/10)
There is still a high quality of life here - although if
you want sophisticated lifestyle elements you have to go off-Island. The
weather is not extreme, but is hardly comparable to exotic tax
havens.
The Island has had a very good run over the last 15
years. Prior to that it was quite simply a bit of a dump. Low unemployment has
led to a lot of people getting opportunities that they would not have got
elsewhere. The Island has become quite complacent. The economy is still quite
shallow and people do not realise quite how quickly things could change for the
worse.
The government has at times been a bit naive in
negotiations on large issues e.g. have agreed to proposals in the name of
development without realising quite how the other party might turn the
situation further to their advantage at the expense of the people living on the
Island.
I think there will be increasing stress on the status of
the Isle of Man as a low-tax location. In particular, privacy will be
increasingly threatened in insidious ways. The Island is too small (and always
subject to a close relationship with the UK) to stand up much for itself. The
best mitigating factor is a very strong democracy - stormcloads ahead are
likely to be spotted. At best over the next 10 years, I expect the Island to
'flatten out' in economic terms. This means that personal investment here will
be low-return (albeit still not high-risk). Things will be flat and quiet
rather than exciting and high-opportunity.
It *is* a beautiful place in it's own way. Living here
depends upon the factors that are important for you in your own quality of
life. You can only expect so much depth in what is after all a small Island
with a population of less than 100,000 people. |
You agree or disagree ???
Well done if you read this far. If you have an interest
in the Isle of Man and disagree with what I say, by all means drop me an email
(to help<at>prosperoassociates.com). I don't promise to do anything about
it, but will try to reciprocate all the courtesy and reasonableness I have
encountered in the Isle of Man for the 20 years I have lived here.
|
Other Isle of Man Web sites
- Manx Forums. The best
online forums for people living in, or interested in, the Isle of Man. If you
want to get a real feel for life on the Island, this is the place to look (or
post).
- Isle of Man Portal. A
fairly comprehensive site associated with Duke Marketing, but
forums/classifieds inactive.
- Isle of Man Guide.
Reasonable coverage, but definitely not neutral. Reads like a tourist office
brochure. Has links to other sites that are not specific to Isle of Man.
- Wikipedia article on
Isle of Man. Fairly good
coverage as you would expect from Wikipedia.
- Isle of Man Government. A
pretty good portal. A lot of information, although some of it is
well-hidden.
- Isle of Man Today.
Run by the parent company of Isle of Man Newspapers, so a lot of content from
local newspaper company (a virtual monopoly). A good example of a newspaper
company putting itself 'on the Internet' and not quite getting it.
|